Archive for September, 2007

El Gaucho - Seattle, WA

Sunday, September 30th, 2007

sp_a0096.jpg

Although the broth tasted amazing and the onions were excellent, the cheese was not melted completely.  If they had left it in the oven a bit longer, this soup would have been outstanding.  The room was dark, so the picture is not very good.  What probably looks like browned cheese is actually parsley.  So, they will lose some ratings points for not cooking it enough, but I will revist this restaurant soon and re-review with some optimism.

 Edit (11/3/07): I revisited, and asked for the cheese to be melted well, and it was very good.

Rating: 7.5 out of 10

Left Bank - Menlo Park, CA

Thursday, September 27th, 2007

sp_a0093.jpg

Nice emmental swiss, and a good amount of it.  The broth could use some work, and I suspect the onions were not adequately caramelized.

Rating: 7 out of 10

Artisanal - New York, NY

Monday, September 10th, 2007

2009-09-19_191237.jpg 

This restaurant is a Mecca for those of us who love cheese.  They use a blend of a few of their hundreds of cheeses on hand to make a fabulous F.O.S.  This makes it a bit non-traditional, yet delicious.  I would never say that an F.O.S. has too much cheese, but I will say for this one that it has not enough soup!  I think a bigger bowl is called for.  However, this would make it tough to tell the difference between their soup and their fondue.  Oh well, such problems!

Edit (11/18/2007): The three cheeses are emmentaler, beaufort, and hoch ybrig.  Picture added.

Edit (09/19/2009): The mystery thickens!  Today I visited Artisanal’s newest location in Bellevue, Washington.  Everything tasted the same, which is a great thing!  However, I asked about the cheeses in the soup, just to make sure.  The server checked with the kitchen, and three different cheeses came back: Emmentaler, fontina, and compté.  Could the Bellevue location make a different soup than the NYC location?  The server said, “non”, and that Chef Brennan makes all of the recipes.  It certainly tasted the same.  So, I called the NYC location, and they now say that the server there made a mistake, and that the cheeses quoted to me were from the fondue, not the onion soup.  That they actually use gruyere and parmesean.

Perhaps they are just trying to hide their recipe?  Who knows.  In any case, a new picture is attached.  The soup/cheese ratio is now perfect!  Please comment on this thread if you manage to find out anything more about my top rated soup!

Edit (06/13/2010) - The Bellevue location has closed

 Rating 9.5 of 10


FireStats icon Powered by FireStats